Sunday, July 17, 2016
At first, it felt heavy-handed, with a ton of exposition being dumped on the reader in the first few pages: a young woman, Rosanna, whose father was a British spy in the Peninsular wars and mother a Portuguese lady is left orphaned in her small house in the countryside outside Lisbon. There is immediate danger from neighbour and supposed benefactor "Dom Luiz" who had wormed his way into her father's society and now has designs on Rosanna Pentallion herself. However, she is quickly saved by the arrival of her aunt and cousin, who take her back to her family estate in England. The narrative relaxed at this point and eased into the real story. I won't go into details, but it has all the classic elements of the gothic romance: the jealous relatives who are up to unrevealed shenanigans, the sworn enemy of her father who also happens to be ruggedly handsome and of good character, hidden wills, dangerous cliffs, miscommunications, faithful servants and so on.
Most of it was kind of predictable, but I still actually got a bit teary when the lovers finally understand each other and I was psyched when the conniving family members got theirs (though Blake pulls the punches with them so that the only real antagonist is Dom Luiz whose "hooked nose, hooded eyes, and excessively swarthy skin hinted of a Moorish strain.").
I am looking forward to finding more of these as I am sure there are some writers in this field who could take the form to an even higher place. As it is, Vanessa Blake did a more than adequate job in keeping me entertained and I hope to see some of the variations that others will bring. Good stuff!
Tuesday, July 12, 2016
I loved the first half, as MacDonald really delves into the setting, giving great details on the church's history, its geography and how it is run. You get to see the database behind its fundraising, the operation that answers (and takes money from) the thousands of letters received each day, the security, the finances, its reslationships with big politicians and so on. Things tend to get a bit saccharine and slightly unreal in parts in the second half, especially as characters have some dialogue that sounds very forced and unnatural. There are a few too many uneducated hicks who somehow have a deep wisdom and a way too rich language to share that wisdom. It also feels a bit rushed and in need of a tighter edit. There are actually several typos, which suggest that it was actually rushed a bit.
Despite those minor flaws, I was hooked enough that I had to stay up late finishing it. Something that happens very rarely to me these days, so I was grateful. I love the way MacDonald doesn't pull his punches on sin. Still in America, the media hems and haws on corruption and immorality of big names and we live in a culture where people still want to defend straight up scumbags because they are powerful or have celebrity. There is none of that doubt in a John D. MacDonald book. He shows you the big name preacher at his worst and it's very satisfying.
Thursday, July 07, 2016
Holy crap, I just did a bit of research and see that Kerr has continued writing Bernie Gunther novels and that there are 11 now!
Sunday, July 03, 2016
So a great setup and there are some rich characters introduced early on that have a lot of promise, the super sinister Lord Caswall whose family is far too Roman in their genealogy and Lady Arabella, who wears a tight white frock to emphasize her impressively slim figure. They are both up to shenanigans it is clear from the start. Unfortunately, the story does not live up to the promise of its beginnings. The pacing is really inconsistent, with big events happening in a sentence while multiple chapters are spent on the nephew and Lord Nathaniel (his ally in fighting the supernatural) theorizing in the most inane way. The plot also just seems to have some major holes where things don't make sense and major events have no impact on any of the characters. It feels badly written. I understand it was Stoker's last book and was published posthumously, but it's a real mess. And I am pretty sure I am reading the unabridged version (there was a popular abridged version that had 28 instead of 40 chapters).
Despite the rough structure, there is a ton of pretty good supernatural action in this book. The protagonists race the great worm in land and sea. Mongooses are ripped in half. And there is a full-on psionic battle that presages Scanners by over 60 years. It's chock full of fun stuff, too bad that so much of it is quite bad. A brief internet search showed me that it has landed on many worst of lists and I think that may have been fair.